How To Order Products In A Collection, And What Each Sort Option Changes
The default sort decides which products fill the first rows of a collection. Each of Shopify's sort options fills those rows differently, and you can also set the order by hand.
Before You Start
- You can edit collections in your Shopify admin.
- You know how many products your theme shows on the first page of a collection. Count the cards on the live page, or look for a products per page setting on the collection template in the theme editor.
Sort order is a sales decision first. The products in the first rows are the ones a shopper sees first, and a shopper who sees chargers and spare parts before the main products may leave. It also changes what the collection page says. We think the first page of a collection is made mostly of its product cards, so the products on it decide much of its text.
What The First Page Is, And Why It Counts Most
A collection with more products than fit on one page is split into pages, or loads more as the shopper scrolls or presses a button. Google's guidance on paginated lists says each page in the series is a separate page with its own address, and that its crawlers do not click buttons. They follow links. So the products on the main collection address, the first page, are the ones that page is made of.
As we see it, a product at position 40 does nothing for the words on the first page, however well it fits the collection. Moving a few strong products up is often enough to change what the page says.
Shopify's Sort Options
Shopify's help lists these choices for a collection's Default sort:
- Most relevant: by sales performance. Shopify's help says new collections use this by default.
- Best selling: by the all-time number of orders that include the product.
- By product title, in alphabetical or reverse alphabetical order.
- By the highest or lowest price. Shopify's help notes that market and B2B catalog prices are not used for this; the base price is.
- By the oldest or newest products, using the date each product was created.
- Manually: the order you set by hand.
What Each Option Means For The Page
Most relevant and Best selling move on their own. A product that sells well rises, which is often what you want. The catch is that accessories and cheap add-ons can sell often and climb above the main products. Check the first rows from time to time.
Alphabetical puts products in order by the first letter of their titles. That rarely matches what a shopper wants first. If your titles start with the brand name, every product from one brand clumps together.
By price puts the cheapest or dearest first. Cheapest first can fill the top of the page with small parts.
By date shows new arrivals first, which suits a collection that is about what is new. On other collections, older core products drift down as you add stock.
Manually is the only option that stays exactly as you set it. It also means new products land wherever Shopify puts them until you move them, so it needs a little upkeep.
How To Change The Default Sort
- From your Shopify admin, go to Products, then Collections.
- Open the collection.
- In the Collection items section, click the Default sort drop-down and choose a sort order.
- Click Save.
How To Set A Manual Order
- Open the collection as above and set Default sort to Manually.
- In the Collection items section, click and hold a product and drag it to its new position.
- To move several at once, select them and use the Move menu. Shopify's help lists To the beginning, To the end, or a specific position.
- Click Save.
In the Shopify app on a phone, open the collection and tap View all in Collection items. Choose Manual from Default sort order, then tap and hold a product to drag it. Shopify's help notes the app offers Move to top and Move to bottom.
Deciding The Order
You do not need to re-sort the whole collection. A few moves usually do it.
- Write down the products in the first page's positions as they are today.
- Mark the ones a shopper searching for this collection would expect to see first.
- Mark the ones that add little: accessories, near copies of another product, items that are out of stock or end of line.
- Swap a few marked products from lower down into the places held by the ones that add little.
- Keep the products that sell well near the top unless you have a good reason to move them.
Example. A store that sells ceramic plant pots sorts its pots collection by Best selling. Saucers and drainage mesh sell often, so they fill four of the first eight places. Moving four pots up into those places changes what the first page is mostly about, without changing any text.
Sort Links In The Address Bar
When a shopper picks a different sort on your collection page, the address gains a sort_by part. Shopify's help says its default robots.txt file includes the rule Disallow: /collections/*sort_by*, which keeps sorted collection pages from being crawled. Our reading is that the order search engines see is your Default sort, because that is the order on the collection's plain address. The article on canonical tags and filters covers these extra addresses in more detail.
Keep Every Product Linked
Google's guidance strongly recommends linking to every product you want indexed, because a crawler may not find a product that no page links to. If you move a product far down a large collection, make sure it is still reachable: on a later page of the collection, in another collection, or from your menus.
If you would rather not work the order out by hand, Collection Optimizer's collection screen does it for a tracked collection. Its New Sort Order card lists every position with how each product got there, and Move These Up From Deeper Pages names the products worth bringing up. The plan turns the moves into one task in the Sort Order group, with each product's old and new position.
How You Know It Worked
- The collection's Default sort shows the option you chose, and the live page lists products in that order.
- The products you meant to lead now appear in the first rows of the live page, and in the same order in the page source.
- If you chose a manual order, the order is the same when you check again a week later. An automatic order such as **Best selling** will drift as sales change.
Sources
- Shopify Help Center: Editing collection details and layout Checked Nov 13, 2026
- Shopify Help Center: Editing robots.txt.liquid Checked Nov 13, 2026
- Google Search Central: Pagination best practices for ecommerce Checked Nov 13, 2026
- Google Search Central: Ecommerce website navigation structure Checked Nov 13, 2026
If a step here no longer matches your admin, tell us at help@collectionoptimizer.com and we will check it again.