Start Free TrialFree Trial

A Product Page Answers At Two Addresses

What the duplicate address fixes on Site Fixes mean, why one product at two addresses splits what it earns, and what to change on Shopify.

In Site Fixes ยท Last Checked

Short Answer

Your store shows the same product at two addresses, such as /products/blue-pot and /collections/pots/products/blue-pot, and the canonical tags do not settle which is the main one. Choose one form, make every canonical tag and link name it, and redirect the other form to it. On Shopify, the usual fix is a theme change so product cards link the plain /products/ address.

These fixes sit under Canonical And Indexing on Site Fixes. Each lists every product it found, with a few example pairs of addresses and a Suggested Fix. There are four kinds:

  • "A product page answers at two addresses, and each one names itself as the main page."
  • "A product page answers at two addresses, and they lack a canonical tag that says which one is the main page."
  • "A product page answers at two addresses, and its canonical tag names the wrong page." For example, it names a page that redirects or is gone.
  • "A product also answers inside a collection's address, and that copy has no canonical tag naming the plain product address."

When it finds several products, each line starts with the count instead.

Why It Matters

Search engines find two pages with the same content and have to pick one. Links and visits the product earns are split between the two addresses, and the choice is left to them. Nothing fires when one form already redirects to the other, or when both canonical tags name the same working address. That is how it should be set up.

What To Change

  1. Choose one form for every product address. On Shopify that is usually the plain /products/your-product form.
  2. Make every canonical tag name it. On Shopify, themes print the canonical tag from a built-in value; a theme or app that changed it needs undoing.
  3. Link the chosen form. If your product cards link the /collections/.../products/... form, ask whoever looks after your theme to link the plain address instead. Shopify's documentation for the filter that builds those links warns about the duplicate content it makes.
  4. Redirect the other form with a permanent (301) redirect, where you can. On Shopify you often cannot from the admin: Shopify's URL redirects work only from addresses that no longer load a page, and never from /products addresses. For the collection form, the canonical tag and the links do the work. For a form that differs only by a slash at the end, the fix says whoever looks after your theme, or the service in front of your store, needs to make the redirect.

Canonical Tags, Filters And Duplicate Collection Pages On Shopify shows how to check your canonical tags in the page source.

How We Know

We crawl both forms of a few pairs of each pattern and judge the rest by what those pairs showed. So a finding can name products whose two forms we did not crawl one by one. Once you have made the change, your next crawl checks it again, and a fix that is no longer found is marked fixed. If you pressed Add To Tasks, the task is verified by a crawl like any other.

Still Stuck?

When a screen in the app shows Tell Us What Went Wrong, use it: the note it opens carries the page you were on, so we can look at the same thing. Otherwise, write to us at help@collectionoptimizer.com, and say which screen you were on and what it said.